Petee's Frequently Asked Questions
Product Info (Allergies, Storage, etc.)
How long do the pies keep?
What’s the best way to reheat my pie?
Can I freeze my pie?
I'm allergic to nuts, are your pies free of nuts?
What size are your pies?
Our pies measure 9 inches across.
How many servings are in each pie?
Our pies serve between 6-8 people. At our store, we typically cut 7 slices out the pies.
Where do you get your ingredients?
For our fillings, we use fresh ingredients from New York state when possible. Our standard crust is made with grassfed butter and organic NY state flour.
Can Petee’s accommodate my special diet?
Yes – we offer gluten free pies. Our only vegan options are the fruit pies and they are gluten free as well. They come with a crumb topping. Note that the topping contains pecans. These can be found under “Gluten Free Pies” and Vegan options are under "Vegan/ Gluten Free Pies) at store.peteespie.com.
We do not offer sugar-free or certified kosher pies.
Logistical Info (Order changes, delivery, etc.)
When should I order my pies?
Do you sell pie by the slice in your shop, if so how much?
Can someone else pick up my order?
Absolutely! As long as that person has the name or order number associated with the order, someone else can pick it up.
I need to make a change to my order, what do I do?
For any changes to your order, please email us at: email@example.com
Does Petee’s deliver or ship?
We currently deliver via courier to Manhattan, most of Brooklyn and parts of Queens. We charge a flat $15 fee which we waive for orders over $90. Go here to see the list of zip codes we service.
We ship nationally through Goldbely.
I’d like to place a large order for a wedding or event- how do I get started?
You can email us at: firstname.lastname@example.org