Petee's In-Store Menu and Info

Everything is available by the slice or as whole 9" pie in-store. We have nearly all of our flavors available (both slices or whole) at any given time, but it's always best to pre-order a whole pie to guarantee that you get what you'd like.


For answers to common questions, reference our FAQ. You can get most of these items delivered throughout Manhattan through Postmates or Caviar. Whole pies can be ordered for pickup or delivery through our site: here.


Standard Pies (Available Year Round):


($5.50 Slice / $30 Whole)

Local Apple 

NY Sour Cherry 

Coconut Custard

Lemon Poppyseed Chess 


($6 slice/ $35 Whole)

Salty Chocolate Chess  

Wild Blueberry

Brown Butter Honey Pecan


Winter Seasonal Pies:


($6 slice/ $35 Whole)

Farm Fresh Pumpkin

Cranberry Apple

Maple Whiskey Walnut



Ice Box Pies (served chilled):

 ($7 slice / $40 whole)

Banana Cream

Coffee & Cream

Chocolate Cream

Key Lime Meringue

Nesselrode Pie



Special Dietary Options:

Gluten Free option available daily by the slice. Call 212-966-2526 for today's availability. If you'd like a GF whole pie, pre-order here. Note that GF fruit pies are also Vegan.




Vanilla Ice Cream

Made from scratch in-house using only natural ingredients.

4oz - $3

Pint - $9


Maple Whipped Cream

Made with real maple syrup and Ronnybrook heavy cream.

Dollop - $1

4oz - $2

Pint - $7


Savory Pies:

6" Chicken Pot Pie with Roasted Seasonal Vegetables ($10)


Other Delicious Things:


Chocolate Oat Cookie ($1)

Cherry Nut Cookie ($1)

Coconut Macaroon (GF) ($1)

Snickerdoodle (Vegan) ($1)

Cinnamon Rolls:

Cinnamon Rolls with Orange Cream Cheese Frosting ($3 each)

Made with Ben's cream cheese and fresh oranges.



 Made with Ben’s cream cheese, fresh orange zest, and real vanilla bean, baked in a butter crumb crust.

($6 slice / $45 whole)

Classic NY Style 


Blueberry or Cherry Topping ($1.50 Dollop/$10 Pint)


Little Pies

4" mini pies in a rotating selection of flavors. ($7 each/4 for $25)