It's Pie Time ⏰

This is our advance ordering page. Looking to place an order for today? CLICK HERE.

Note: Cutoff for next day orders are 3pm the day before

Holiday Menu

Eggnog Cheesecake - 24 Hours Notice Required
Eggnog Cheesecake $ 48.00
Nesselrode Pie
Nesselrode Pie $ 45.00
Mince Pie
Mince Pie $ 45.00
Little Pie Gift Sets
Little Pie Gift Sets $ 28.00
Julekake
Julekake $ 15.00

Our Full Pie Line-up

Petee's Junior Pies
Petee's Junior Pies From $ 15.00
Hudson Valley Apple Pie
Hudson Valley Apple Pie $ 40.00
Hudson Valley Apple Crumb
Hudson Valley Apple Crumb $ 40.00
Sour Cherry
Sour Cherry $ 40.00
Sour Cherry Crumb
Sour Cherry Crumb $ 40.00
Wild Maine Blueberry
Wild Maine Blueberry $ 40.00
Wild Blueberry Crumb
Wild Blueberry Crumb $ 40.00
Salty Chocolate Chess
Salty Chocolate Chess $ 40.00
Black Bottom Almond Chess
Black Bottom Almond Chess $ 40.00
Brown Butter Honey Pecan
Brown Butter Honey Pecan $ 40.00
Maple Whiskey Walnut
Maple Whiskey Walnut 🆕 $ 40.00
Coconut Custard
Coconut Custard $ 35.00
Sweet Potato 🆕
Sweet Potato 🆕 $ 35.00
Farm Fresh Pumpkin Pie
Farm Fresh Pumpkin Pie 🆕 $ 35.00
Key Lime Meringue
Key Lime Meringue $ 45.00
Lemon Meringue Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie $ 45.00
Lavish Chocolate Cream
Lavish Chocolate Cream $ 45.00
Banana Cream
Banana Cream $ 45.00
Classic NY Cheesecake
Classic NY Cheesecake $ 48.00

Ice Cream and Whip

Pint of Maple Whip Cream
Pint of Maple Whip Cream $ 7.00
Pint of Vanilla Ice Cream
Pint of Vanilla Ice Cream $ 9.00
Pint of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream
Pint of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream $ 9.00
Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream
Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream $ 9.00

Savories

Chicken Pot Pie
Chicken Pot Pie $ 13.00

Petee's Farm Store

On sale
Pie for Everyone: Recipes and Stories from Petee's Pie
Pie for Everyone: Recipes and Stories from Petee's Pie $ 24.00 $ 30.00
Petee's Sweatshirt
Petee's Sweatshirt $ 30.00
Petee's Black Sweatshirt
Petee's Black Sweatshirt $ 30.00
Honey Moon - Cloud Forest Camp Mug
Honey Moon - Cloud Forest Camp Mug $ 25.00