amazon-payments amex bitcoin cirrus discover fancy google-wallet interact jcb mastercard paypal stripe twitter visa diners-club dankort apple-pay facebook google-plus instagram maestro pinterest rss tumblr vimeo youtube arrow-bottom arrow-right arrow-left arrow-top cross search user cart minus plus arrow-right-2 comment
Take care of yourselves and each other. We ❤️you!
Contact (646)-494-3630 orders@peteespie.com
  • Open menu
    • COOKBOOK
    • 9" Pies
    • 6" Junior Pies
    • Savories
    • Alcohol
    • Ice Cream & More
    • Groceries
    • Merch
    • Contact
  • 0
  • Skip to navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Petee's Pie Co.
  • Login
  • Register
  • Cart (0)
  • COOKBOOK
  • 9" Pies
  • 6" Junior Pies
  • Savories
  • Alcohol
  • Ice Cream & More
  • Groceries
  • Merch
  • Contact

It's Pie Time ⏰

We deliver within a 50 mile radius of each of our locations

We require 16 hour notice for any orders on this page. For same day orders, more flexible fulfillment times, slices and ready-to-eat food: ORDER HERE

Featured Flavors:

Petee's Mean Slice T-Shirt
Petee's Mean Slice T-Shirt $ 25.00
Pie for Everyone: Recipes and Stories from Petee's Pie
Pie for Everyone: Recipes and Stories from Petee's Pie $ 29.99
Pie Kit
Pie Kit $ 40.00
Chicken Pot Pie
Chicken Pot Pie $ 13.00
Cheese & Onion Pot Pie
Cheese & Onion Pot Pie $ 13.00
Chile Garlic Beef Shank Pot Pie
Chile Garlic Beef Shank Pot Pie $ 14.00
Petee's Junior Pies
Petee's Junior Pies $ 15.00
6" Seasonal Quiche
6" Seasonal Quiche $ 12.00
Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream
Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream $ 9.00
Pint of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream
Pint of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream $ 9.00
Maple Pecan Granola
Maple Pecan Granola $ 7.50
Bake at Home Cookies
Bake at Home Cookies $ 12.00

Our Full 9" Pie Line-up

Hudson Valley Apple Pie
Hudson Valley Apple Pie $ 35.00
Hudson Valley Apple Crumb
Hudson Valley Apple Crumb $ 35.00
Sour Cherry
Sour Cherry $ 35.00
Sour Cherry Crumb
Sour Cherry Crumb $ 35.00
Wild Maine Blueberry
Wild Maine Blueberry $ 35.00
Wild Blueberry Crumb
Wild Blueberry Crumb $ 35.00
Salty Chocolate Chess
Salty Chocolate Chess $ 35.00
Black Bottom Almond Chess
Black Bottom Almond Chess $ 35.00
Brown Butter Honey Pecan
Brown Butter Honey Pecan $ 35.00
Coconut Custard
Coconut Custard $ 35.00
Key Lime Meringue
Key Lime Meringue $ 40.00
Lemon Meringue Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie $ 40.00
Lavish Chocolate Cream
Lavish Chocolate Cream $ 40.00
Banana Cream
Banana Cream $ 40.00
Maple Whiskey Walnut
Maple Whiskey Walnut $ 35.00
Black Currant Streusel
Black Currant Streusel $ 35.00
Gluten Free Pies
Gluten Free Pies $ 40.00
Vegan/ Gluten Free Pies
Vegan/ Gluten Free Pies $ 40.00
Blood Orange Cheesecake
Blood Orange Cheesecake $ 53.00
Classic NY Cheesecake
Classic NY Cheesecake $ 45.00

Natural Wine, Local Beer, Booze (now offering Manhattan delivery)

Divella Blanc de Blancs
Divella Blanc de Blancs $ 40.00
Moonstones Chenin Blanc
Moonstones Chenin Blanc $ 32.00
Marine 2018
Marine 2018 $ 28.00
Tète Nat - Igny Rusé Rosé Sparkling
Tète Nat - Igny Rusé Rosé Sparkling $ 28.00
Lunedì Rosato
Lunedì Rosato $ 26.00
Pampaneo Ancestral
Pampaneo Ancestral $ 24.00
Entre les gouttes
Entre les gouttes $ 24.00
Benastra petite soeur
Benastra petite soeur $ 22.00
Weight of the Moment
Weight of the Moment $ 20.00
St. Agrestis, Negroni 100ml
St. Agrestis, Negroni 100ml From $ 9.00
St. Agrestis, Amaro (50ml)
St. Agrestis, Amaro (50ml) $ 5.50
Lindner's Cider
Lindner's Cider $ 13.50
Transmitter Biere De Garde
Transmitter Biere De Garde From $ 6.50
Grimm 'Lilt'
Grimm 'Lilt' $ 19.50
Grimm 'Arpa Darpa 692'
Grimm 'Arpa Darpa 692' From $ 7.50
Threes Brewing 'Logical Conclusion'
Threes Brewing 'Logical Conclusion' From $ 6.25
Arrowood ‘Porch Beer’
Arrowood ‘Porch Beer’ From $ 6.50

Petee's Farm Market

Pie Kit
Pie Kit $ 40.00
5 Spoke Creamery Cheddar Cheese (7oz)
5 Spoke Creamery Cheddar Cheese (7oz) $ 6.75
Elmhurst Oat Milk (1 Quart)
Elmhurst Oat Milk (1 Quart) $ 6.68
Parlor Coffee Beans (8 oz) Colombia Los Angeles
Parlor Coffee Beans (8 oz) From $ 14.00
Champlain Valley Milling Flour (2 Pounds)
Champlain Valley Milling Flour (2 Pounds) $ 3.12
Beth's Farm Kitchen Hot Pepper Jelly (8 oz jar)
Beth's Farm Kitchen Hot Pepper Jelly (8 oz jar) $ 9.30
Bake at Home Cookies
Bake at Home Cookies $ 12.00

61 Delancey Street 10002

Sun - Sat: 11AM - 11PM

505 Myrtle Ave

Sun - Thur: 9AM - 10PM Fri - Sat: 9AM - 11PM

Newsletter

ADA Compliance Policy:

Petee's is committed to keeping our site compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act. We welcome any feedback on how to improve the site’s accessibility for all users.

    Net Orders Checkout

    Item Price Qty Total
    Subtotal $ 0.00
    Shipping
    Total

    Shipping Address

    Shipping Methods