The Best Pie in NYC - Order a Pie Now!

It's Pie Time ⏰

Note: Cutoff for next day orders are 3pm. If after 3PM call us at 212-966-2526.

If looking to order pies for today go here instead.

Strawberry Rhubarb

$ 40.00

Spring Cordial Pie 🆕

$ 45.00

Guava Mascarpone Pie 🆕

$ 45.00

6" Dirt Pie (Earth Day Special)

$ 20.00

Classic Lemon Chess

$ 40.00

9" Quiche (Easter Special)

$ 40.00

Petee's Junior Pies

$ 18.00

Hudson Valley Apple Pie

$ 40.00

Hudson Valley Apple Crumb

$ 40.00

Sour Cherry

$ 40.00

Sour Cherry Crumb

$ 40.00

Wild Maine Blueberry

$ 40.00

Coconut Custard

$ 40.00

Wild Blueberry Crumb

$ 40.00

Salty Chocolate Chess

$ 40.00

Black Bottom Almond Chess

$ 40.00

Brown Butter Honey Pecan

$ 40.00

Key Lime Meringue

$ 45.00

Lavish Chocolate Cream

$ 45.00

Banana Cream

$ 45.00

Classic NY Cheesecake

$ 55.00

Pint of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream

$ 9.00

Pint of Maple Whip Cream

$ 7.00

Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream

$ 9.00

Pint of Vanilla Ice Cream

$ 9.00

Storage

HOW LONG DO THE PIES KEEP?

Fruit pies are best stored on the counter and eaten within 4 days of purchase.

Custard pies (including pumpkin and sweet potato) are best eaten within 2 days of purchase if stored on the counter, however they can also be refrigerated for up to a week.

Chess and nut pies can last up to a week on the counter.

Cream pies must be refrigerated and are best eaten within two days of purchase.

Meringue pies also must be refrigerated and are best eaten within 4 days of purchase.

WHAT’S THE BEST WAY TO REHEAT MY PIE?

The pies are fulfilled at room tempature (or cold in the case of our Ice Box Pies). You can reheat a pie by putting it uncovered in a 350 degree oven for 20 minutes. The chess, nut, fruit, and even custard pies are lovely served warm. They can also be enjoyed at room tempature.

Petee's Pie Co.

It's Pie Time ⏰

Our Full Pie Line-up

Ice Cream and Whip Cream

Storage

Other