It's Pie Time ⏰
We deliver within a 50 mile radius of each of our locations
We require 16 hour notice for any orders on this page. For same day orders, more flexible fulfillment times, slices and ready-to-eat food: ORDER HERE
Featured Flavors:
Petee's Mean Slice T-Shirt
$ 25.00
Pie Kit
$ 40.00
Chicken Pot Pie
$ 13.00
Cheese & Onion Pot Pie
$ 13.00
Chile Garlic Beef Shank Pot Pie
$ 14.00
Petee's Junior Pies
$ 15.00
6" Seasonal Quiche
$ 12.00
Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream
$ 9.00
Maple Pecan Granola
$ 7.50
Bake at Home Cookies
$ 12.00
Our Full 9" Pie Line-up
Hudson Valley Apple Pie
$ 35.00
Hudson Valley Apple Crumb
$ 35.00
Sour Cherry
$ 35.00
Sour Cherry Crumb
$ 35.00
Wild Maine Blueberry
$ 35.00
Wild Blueberry Crumb
$ 35.00
Salty Chocolate Chess
$ 35.00
Black Bottom Almond Chess
$ 35.00
Brown Butter Honey Pecan
$ 35.00
Coconut Custard
$ 35.00
Key Lime Meringue
$ 40.00
Lemon Meringue Pie
$ 40.00
Lavish Chocolate Cream
$ 40.00
Banana Cream
$ 40.00
Maple Whiskey Walnut
$ 35.00
Black Currant Streusel
$ 35.00
Gluten Free Pies
$ 40.00
Vegan/ Gluten Free Pies
$ 40.00
Blood Orange Cheesecake
$ 53.00
Classic NY Cheesecake
$ 45.00
Natural Wine, Local Beer, Booze (now offering Manhattan delivery)
Divella Blanc de Blancs
$ 40.00
Moonstones Chenin Blanc
$ 32.00
Marine 2018
$ 28.00
Lunedì Rosato
$ 26.00
Pampaneo Ancestral
$ 24.00
Entre les gouttes
$ 24.00
Benastra petite soeur
$ 22.00
Weight of the Moment
$ 20.00
St. Agrestis, Negroni 100ml
From $ 9.00
St. Agrestis, Amaro (50ml)
$ 5.50
Lindner's Cider
$ 13.50
Transmitter Biere De Garde
From $ 6.50
Grimm 'Lilt'
$ 19.50
Grimm 'Arpa Darpa 692'
From $ 7.50
Threes Brewing 'Logical Conclusion'
From $ 6.25
Arrowood ‘Porch Beer’
From $ 6.50
Petee's Farm Market
Pie Kit
$ 40.00
Elmhurst Oat Milk (1 Quart)
$ 6.68
Parlor Coffee Beans (8 oz)
From $ 14.00
Bake at Home Cookies
$ 12.00